Skip to Main Content
1 (800) 929-3667 (Door) Request a Quote Find a Distributor
Overhead Door
    • Garage Doors by Style
    • All Residential Garage Doors
    • Garage Door Openers
    • Garage Door Accessories
    • Wind Load Garage Doors
    • Residential Gate Operators

    • Resources

      • DoorDreamer® : View any Door on Your Home in Seconds
      • Repair My Garage Door
      • Programming Instructions
    • Commercial Product Categories
    • All Commercial Doors
    • Commercial Operators
    • Commercial Accessories
    • Loading Dock Equipment
      • Automotive
      • Family Housing
      • Food & Beverage
      • Government Facilities
      • Healthcare
      • Manufacturing
      • Parking Garage
      • Public Facilities
      • Security
      • Warehouse Solutions

    • Commercial Resources

      • Commercial Door Repair
    • Overview
    • Repair My Garage Door
    • Commercial Door Repair
    • Repair vs. Replace
    • Garage Door Opener Repair

      • Find a Distributor
    • Overview
    • Brochures
    • Warranty
    • Owners Manuals
    • Commercial Specs
    • Residential Specs
    • Dock Installation Instructions

      • DoorView - Configurator
    • Overview
    • Customize Architectural Drawings
    • BIM Object Library
    • CAD Drawings
    • Specifications

    • Additional Resources

      • Customize Architectural Drawings
      • Resources
      • Brochures
  • Home
  • About Garage Doors
  • Garage Door Materials

How to Choose a Garage Door Material

Garage Door Material Popularity Guide

Selecting the appropriate garage door material is essential for enhancing your home's aesthetics, security, and functionality. Each material has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. This guide aims to assist you in evaluating the pros and cons of steel, aluminum, vinyl, fiberglass, wind load, and wood garage doors, so you can make a well-informed choice. The process can be daunting, but knowing the popularity of each material can simplify your decision-making. Here’s a ranking of garage door materials based on their popularity:

  1. Steel
  2. Aluminum
  3. Vinyl
  4. Wood
  5. Fiberglass
  6. Wind Load
carriage house double car garage door

Steel Garage Doors

Popularity: Very High

Steel is the most popular garage door material due to its durability, security, and variety of styles. Homeowners appreciate its low maintenance requirements and cost-effectiveness, making it a top choice.

Pros:
  1. Durability: Steel doors are incredibly durable and can withstand harsh weather conditions.
  2. Insulation Layers Available: Helps with wind, temperature, sound infiltration and energy efficiency.
  3. Security: Offers excellent security, as they are hard to break into.
  4. Low Maintenance: Requires minimal maintenance.
  5. Variety: Available in a wide range of styles and finishes including wood-grain textures.
  6. Cost-Effective: Budget-friendly depending on needs.
aluminum full view garage

Aluminum Garage Doors

Popularity: High

Aluminum doors are popular for their lightweight nature and modern aesthetics. They are particularly favored in coastal regions due to their corrosion resistance.

Pros:
  1. Lightweight: Easier to install and less strain on the door’s operating mechanism.
  2. Corrosion-Resistant: Ideal for coastal environments.
  3. Modern Aesthetics: Often used for contemporary and sleek designs.
vinyle garage door

Vinyl Garage Doors

Popularity: Moderate to High

Vinyl doors have gained popularity because of their durability and low maintenance. Their resistance to dents and moisture makes them a preferred choice in areas with harsh weather conditions.

Pros:
  1. Durability: Highly resistant to dents and cracks.
  2. Low Maintenance: Virtually maintenance free and is easy to clean.
  3. Moisture-Resistant: Perfect for humid climates as they resist rust and corrosion.
wood garage door custom made

Wood Garage Doors

Popularity: Moderate

Wood doors are beloved for their classic and natural look. While they require more maintenance and are more expensive, their aesthetic appeal keeps them popular among homeowners who prioritize curb appeal.

Pros:
  1. Aesthetics: Offers a natural and classic look, enhancing curb appeal.
  2. Customization: Easily customizable with different stains and designs.
  3. Insulation: Naturally good insulator, keeping garages warmer in winter and cooler in summer.
fiberglass garage door

Fiberglass Garage Doors

Popularity: Moderate

Fiberglass doors are chosen for their lightweight nature and ability to mimic wood. However, their susceptibility to fading and brittleness in cold climates makes them less popular than steel or aluminum.

Pros:
  1. Lightweight: Easy to install and operate.
  2. Durability: Resistant to dents, cracks, and rust.
  3. Customizable: Can mimic the look of wood at a lower cost.
  4. Low Maintenance: Repainted or refurbished once every 1-3 years and does not diminish in quality over time like real wood can.
wind load rated garage

Wind Load Garage Doors

Popularity: Niche

Wind load doors are essential in hurricane-prone areas but are less popular in regions without severe weather conditions. Their additional cost and limited design options make them a specialized choice.

Pros:
  1. Strength: Built to withstand high winds and extreme weather conditions.
  2. Safety: Provides extra safety for homes in hurricane-prone areas.
  3. Insurance: May reduce homeowner’s insurance premiums.

LEARN MORE

Conclusion

Steel doors lead the pack in popularity due to their balance of durability, security, and affordability. Aluminum and vinyl doors follow, appreciated for their specific benefits in different environments. Wood doors remain a classic choice for their beauty, while fiberglass offers a middle ground. Wind load doors, though crucial in certain regions, serve a more niche market.

Choosing the right garage door material depends on your priorities, budget, and the climate you live in. By understanding the popularity of each material, you can better gauge what might be the best fit for your home and your personal preferences.

Find a Distributor

Overhead Door

1 (800) 929-3667 (DOOR)

Homeowners

  • All Residential Garage Doors
  • DoorDreamer® : View any Door on Your Home in Seconds
  • Repair My Garage Door
  • Smart Home Hub

Professionals

  • Commercial
  • Architects
  • Loading Dock Equipment
  • DoorView - Configurator

Useful links

  • About Us
  • Blogs
  • News
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • © 2025 Overhead Door. All rights Reserved.
  •  Legal
  •  Privacy Policy
  •  Sitemap
  • Supply Chain Ethics Policy