Repair vs. Replace

5 Steps to Decide on Repairing or

Replacing Your Garage Door

repair vs replace garage door

Garage doors endure heavy usage in our busy lives, opening and closing roughly 1,500 times annually as families navigate daily routines. This constant use can lead to wear and tear such as cracked panels, chipped paint, and worn parts. Addressing these issues promptly is crucial, as neglecting minor damage can escalate into more significant problems over time. Moreover, damaged garage doors not only compromise security but also invite pests and increase energy costs by allowing air infiltration.

A damaged garage door affects more than just functionality—it impacts your home's appearance and energy efficiency. Whether to repair or replace depends on various factors, including the extent of damage, cost-effectiveness, and desired aesthetic appeal. Below, we'll explore different scenarios to help you make an informed decision that enhances the safety, aesthetics, and functionality of your home. 


(800) 887-3667 (DOOR)

Consider the Type of Garage Door Damage

Your garage door might suffer from either minor, moderate, or serious damage:

Minor damage typically involves cosmetic issues like chipped paint or small cracks that don't affect the door's function. In such cases, repairing the door usually offers more value than replacing it.

Moderate damage extends beyond cosmetic concerns to affect the structural integrity of the door. Warping or rusting may hinder its operation and compromise security. Considering such structural damage, replacing the door becomes a more viable option.

Serious damage renders the door non-functional, leading to issues like sticking, squealing noises, intermittent operation, or complete failure to open. In these instances, replacing the door with a new, fully functional one is often necessary. However, it's advisable to rule out simple fixes such as replacing batteries or springs before opting for a replacement.


garage door damage repair

What is the Extent of Your Garage Door Repairs

Reflect on the frequency of repairs needed for the door. If repairs are becoming increasingly frequent or if the cost of repairs exceeds the value of the door, replacement may be more cost-effective in the long run. Assess the overall condition of the door, including the condition of components such as springs, cables, rollers, and tracks. Extensive damage to these components may require comprehensive repairs or replacement of the entire door.

Garage Door Repair Circumstances

If you notice a significant increase in the weight of your garage door when operating it manually, this usually signifies a problem with the springs. It's crucial to have these springs replaced promptly as the added weight can strain the door's motor.

In the case of a damaged panel, a repair should suffice. While a damaged garage door panel isn't overly serious initially, prompt action is recommended to prevent cracks from spreading. Replacing the damaged panel is crucial to safeguarding your garage interior from the elements.

A crooked or sagging door often indicates a problem with the torsion springs responsible for most of the door's heavy lifting. Fortunately, replacing these springs is a relatively simple solution that eliminates the need for a new door.

If your garage door fails to open immediately upon sensing an obstruction, scheduling a repair is necessary. This issue suggests a malfunction with the mandated sensors designed to prevent injuries to individuals, particularly children and pets, and requires prompt attention.

If your garage door has abruptly ceased functioning and it's not due to depleted batteries, it's advisable to seek a repair. The issue might stem from a component within the door's mechanism, such as a burnt-out motor, a snapped belt or chain, or a broken spring, all of which a technician can swiftly diagnose and rectify.